When new evidence of a murder case from 1979 is found, Det. Jeffries, who worked on the case as a rookie cop, sets out to find the killer, fulfilling the promise he made to the victim's daughter 27 years ago.
Jed Huxley is arrested for murder.
- Kathryn Morris as Lilly Rush
- Danny Pino as Scotty Valens
- John Finn as John Stillman
- Jeremy Ratchford as Nick Vera
- Thom Barry as Will Jeffries
- Tracie Thoms as Kat Miller
- Nestor Carbonell as Mike Valens
- Annie Wersching as Libby Bradley (1979)
- Tay Blessey as Helen Bradley (1979)
- Ben Bode as Jed Huxley (2006)
- Allison Dunbar as Alison Huxley (1979)
- Matthew Glave as Carl Bradley (1979)
- Jay Huguley as Joe Livingston (1979)
- Ele Keats as Helen Bradley (2006)
- George Newbern as Bill Huxley (1979)
- Robert Pine as Carl Bradley (2006)
- Bonnie Root as ADA Alexandra Thomas
- Mark L. Young as Jed Huxley (1979)
- Diane Cary as Alison Huxley (2006)
- Eugene Robert Glazer as Joe Livingston (2006)
- J. Patrick McCormack as Bill Huxley (2006)
- Darwin Harris as Will Jeffries (1979)
- Angela Little as Julie Livingston
- James Henrie as Young Mike Valens (1983)
- Allen Alvarado as Young Scotty Valens (1983)
- This episode uses some elements from the 1997 film The Ice Storm.
- Steve Jablonski's case box is visible when the detectives are examining Libby Bradley's case box in the case room.
- Actress Tay Blessey and actor George Newbern later starred on the hit tv show, Criminal Minds, episode Soul Mates, together.
- The Emotions "Best Of My Love"
- Dr. Hook "Sharing The Night Together"
- Styx "Babe"
- David Naughton "Makin' It"
- Leo Sayer "When I Need You"
- Closing Song: Anne Murray "Broken Hearted Me"
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.