Cold Case Wiki
Advertisement
Jill Shelby
Jill in 1976
Jill Shelby
Portrayed by Kate Mara
Episode Look Again
Status Deceased (1976)

Jill Shelby was a 15-year-old girl who was brutally beaten to death by her obsessive and controlling boyfriend, then 17-year-old Todd Whitley, in a violent rage over his anger after seeing her make out with his younger brother, then 15-year-old Eric Whitley. He was also furious over Jill back-talking to him and her standing up for Eric. The incident started over Jill discovering that Todd was cheating on her with her best friend, then-15-year-old Melanie.

Advertisement